Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Sly Fawkes's avatar

A hearty HELL YES to all of this. One of the biggest problems with the "ob*sity as a disease" rhetoric is the idea that having a body of a certain size is a disease in and of itself. Having a large body can be correlated with certain health conditions (often endocrine imbalances) so it would be prudent for healthcare professionals to be on the lookout for such conditions in larger patients as revealed by lab work. However, telling fat patients that losing weight will improve their health and decrease their risk of (laundry list of health problems generally associated with growing older, such as heart conditions, hypertension and risk of developing type 2 diabetes) is about as logical as telling a man with pattern baldness that getting hair plugs will decrease his risk of developing prostate cancer. While a large body type can indicate certain underlying health problems, it isn't a health problem in and of itself.

Of course larger people also have to deal with the erroneous assumptions that we are constantly stuffing ourselves with "bad" food. Us fatties would be thin tomorrow if we'd just eat a salad, dontcha know? ;-)

Joking aside, if a person does suffer from binge eating disorder, one would think they would respond better to compassionate treatment than to shaming. Just a thought. However, not all heavy people have binge eating disorder. I would say the majority of us big folk are well-versed in restrictive eating. If you're looking at a fat person, it's very likely you're looking at someone who has participated in dieting in an attempt to reduce their size, probably more than once.

Expand full comment
MJ's avatar

Today I did something I have been meaning to do for weeks - look at what many so-called "ob*sity experts" have to say on their social media platforms/blogs/whatevers about this whole AAP mess.

Most of them say nothing. Even the ones that I used to respect until they started worshiping at the holy altar of WLS have nothing to say about it.

One I found was such condescending garbage. They spouted how WLS is safer than ever! There are new drugs that are safer than ever! (with no citations for either, and for the drugs, safer than what? The one drug that makes you poop yourself sick, or fen/phen which they pretty much knew was dangerous from the start, or the stuff they used 50 years ago - actual speed and/or thyroid hormones?) It then went on to complain in the most condescending language that the people who are against the AAP statement "don't understand the needs of these poor suffering children and their families." Like, [censored censored censored] with a [censored], you demeaning excuse for a human being.

The majority of people who are making noises about this are Registered Dietitians - most of whom are condemning it and ripping it to shreds - and fat activists. In the end it's you and others doing the work to reveal the truths who will be saving the world from this horrific crap which is the *actual* risk to the lives of children and teenagers.

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts