Discussion about this post

User's avatar
jen's avatar

It’s amazing how industry doesn’t even try to hide its ties to these orgs.

Im not sure it’s an equal comparison using pain management and Purdue pharma as an analogy though.

As horrible as Purdue was, they convinced a ton of doctors that pain was real and deserved treatment. They did this the absolute wrong way, and used bad science to do it. But a lot of doctors were swayed by the sales pitch and PYT drug reps flirting and flattering, and people got pain management. (Not always good quality if they were getting OxyContin, but still.) then the war on drugs backfired and now pain patients are being punished, but still.

There is zero medical benefit to doing this with weight loss. And ultimately, I doubt the government is ever going to intervene and say that fat people deserve evidence based medicine, and ban these terrible drugs and surgeries.

That would be amazing if it happened though. Someday long after we are all gone, historians will look back on this time and be utterly horrified by the things the medical industry used to do to fat people.

Expand full comment
Jennifer Todd's avatar

Another stupid question, but am I wrong to have a suspicion that the CDC could decide to further restrict the BMI categories, as they did in 1998? Redefine even more people medically obese? Or possibly redefine “overweight” as “pre-obesity”, as they defined “pre-diabetes “?

I’m suspicious because of they way this guideline targets people of Asian decent for no medical or scientific reason, redefining their health risks at separate BMI category.

Maybe you can tell, this stuff really makes me both very upset and heartbroken!

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts